Catto's Post Office

When I was in third grade, I wrote a play. The thing about this play, though, was that I was eight years old and did not know what a script was, nor did I understand that plays are things meant to be rehearsed in advance. What I actually wrote was five or so lines that represented what one of the characters might say, and expected everyone else in the “play” to know their lines in turn. I then wanted to perform my play, but being a lonely and friendless eight year old who lived in a museum (I will accept no follow-up questions about this), the only place I could perform my play and the only people I could get to perform it were my classmates in a classroom when the teacher wasn’t paying enough attention to stop me.

I had a plan. In the hubbub following in the wake of a bunch of eight year olds coming back from lunch, I grabbed a few of my classmates and dragged them to the front of Ms. Syverson’s classroom for the world premiere of my very first play. Whether this play ever had a plot, I do not know. What I do know is that it opened with a rousing of rendition of “Happy Birthday.”

And so, I stood at the front of the classroom, leading first the students I had kidnapped and then the entire classroom in a semi-united choir of “Happy Birthday” to no one in particular while Ms. Syverson, baffled and overwhelmed, tried desperately to get me to please just stop whatever it was I was up to. When the song ended, she burst into applause that I - being eight years old - took as an indicator that she loved my play, before being ushered back to my seat with the vain prayer that I might actually stay there for once in my life.

Catto’s Post Office reminds me a lot of that play. It is baffling, appears out of nowhere, disappears just as quickly, and rewards itself with thoroughly unearned applause at the end of whatever this is that it’s trying to pass off as existence.

god if only i could

Catto’s Post Office is cosy adventure game, using the loosest possible definition of “adventure.” You play as Catto, a cat who - get this - delivers packages for the local postal service. Over the course of the game, Catto delivers packages to the town’s various feline denizens, helping them with their problems even while struggling with the sneaking suspicion that all of them have forgotten his birthday.

Look. I’m not going to pretend I don’t play cosy games or that I don’t understand them. I do. I promise I do. Cosy games are a sweet little niche that, instead of encouraging me to be my normal crotchety old self, awaken that little nubbin of warmth that somehow survives down in the depths of whatever it is I have masquerading as a heart. There are even some cosy games I like. Hell, if we want to get really technical, I have a cosy fantasy series lurking like a red-headed stepchild in my back catalogue. My point is, I have no issue with cosy as a concept.

What I think is a distinction worth making, though, is the line between “cosy” and “mindless.” Good cosy media succeeds because it’s contrasting with the bleak stuff out there, whether that be other media or reality itself. This is in not only the vibes, but the idea of the game and the concepts underpinning it. Cosy is defined by its embrace of friendship, love, and acceptance. It’s filled with found families, big hugs, and warm cups of cocoa.

For all of that to work and feel meaningful, though, there needs to be at least some amount of ideas present in whatever the media is. It isn’t enough to show friendship. Rather, the cosiness works when that friendship feels earned through some amount of struggle. Friendship is something that worked for and worth it because of the work that goes into building it. Cosiness is meaningful because it exists in contrast to a crapsack world, not because it exhibits the tropes and vibes in and of itself. Without some amount of friction, cosiness descends into saccharine twee-ness, too caught up in its own vibes to ask anything at all of the person playing it.

Mindlessness isn’t cosiness. It’s just mindlessness.

Someday, I'm going to be put in the millennial nursing home, and the old people around me are going to be saying "eepy," and I'm going to die just to avoid them.

There is nothing of substance in Catto’s Post Office. The description I provided of a cat delivering packages is literally the sum total of this roughly half hour game. In other games, delivering packages is the basis for developing characters, shaping narratives about journeys and transformation, or as a means by which to explore a world. Not in Catto’s Post Office. In Catto’s Post Office, you deliver packages to immediately forgettable cat figures who spout bad cat puns, then meow at you. Any changes you make to the world are undone the moment you turn your back. Any incentive to explore the world is nullified by how obvious everything is and how tiny the world actually is. Every conversation looks exactly the same. It is a boring, empty, nothing world populated by cat-shaped blob things. There is nothing to do here and no reason to engage with it except maybe to kill half an hour, and even then, the videos of birds played for actual cats provide more engaging content than anything presented in Catto’s Post Office.

This is, of course, not to say that every game needs to be the pinnacle of engagement. Not everything needs to be the next GTA VI. However, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask that a game offer something and not treat me like I’m a moron incapable of thought. This is a game that made me keenly aware of my brain leaking out my ears, and how I had not only chosen to do this to myself, but pay someone for the privilege of doing so.

I do not like Catto’s Post Office. I do not think it is a very good game. I do not recommend it.

Developer: In Shambles Studio
Genre: Cosy
Year: 2025
Country: Australia
Language: English
Time to Complete: 30 minutes
Playthrough: https://youtu.be/lVR0AIuqNY8